Red edit hiccup

I’m still in the red edit zone, so no completed chart just yet. Instead I have these:

Yes, I’m making the grievous error of not just a prologue, or epilogue, but both!

But, let’s gloss over that for now.

My red edits have gone really well, and I technically finished them last night, after a full-on day of reading my own words, cringing, and occasionally being wow-ed.  In fact, there are several pages which don’t even have any edits on them at all!

I added reason and sense to some of the plot points that were somewhat lacking, and a bit of emotion where I’d forgotten to show it. I cut a lot of useless stuff, including a whole character (RIP MC’s boyfriend, but he was kind of pointless, and ended the relationship in the same chapter he was introduced).

Despite all the cutting – some days, I hovered around the exact same number, even though I was writing furiously – I added 2261 words to the story, which means it now stands at just over 40,000! Still too short for a novel, but on my way. By adding four more chapters, I should easily make that up to 45,000.

I swapped around some of the early chapters, but I’m still not completely happy. The opening feels sluggish and dull – but I think it’s necessary to set the scene. Due to the nature of the story, I can’t use flashbacks (which I usually love, so this is hard for me). Perhaps, when I get to the beta reader stage, fresh eyes will be able to point out the problems.

Big question: Prologues and epilogues, love them or hate them?



22 thoughts on “Red edit hiccup”

  1. I like prologues and epilogues! But I know they have gone out of vogue with editors and agents…but then I open up a best seller and there’s – you guessed it! A prologue! And an Epilogue! So do your own thing!


    1. I think if they’re used badly, like to dump the reader in something really exciting, but then the main story start with them shopping in a supermarket, it can be like a false advertisement. I’ve seen some done really well, and give the reader an a-ha moment later on in the story.


  2. I really like them, especially when they shed light on something in the main plot that just can’t be addressed in that plot – like if you aren’t using flashbacks. On occassion, I don’t like prologues and epilogues, but that’s in the fantasy epics which also include glossaries of characters and five maps – all very interesting but sometimes a bit much for me. However, I know that many readers like having all of those extras. I like prologues and epilogues best in shorter novels like yours.


  3. I like them. They set the stage for the book and provide a nice, tidy wrap-up.

    Fresh eyes will probably help you with those sluggish areas.


  4. Happy to beta read whenever you’re ready! It sounds like you’ve got a lot of work done, so that’s great.

    As not everyone seems keen on prologues and epilogues, if you can make them a reasonable length, it might be worth offering them as supplementary books that readers can pick up if they want to know more – perhaps as freebies. Anything’s possible these days!


    1. Thanks for the offer, will definitely take you up on it 🙂

      The pro- and epilogues will be very short chapters, definitely nothing worth making longer, but long enough to explain what I need to.


  5. I like them a lot. I think they set the mood – prologue. And I like a tidy tie-up with an epilogue. Very satisfying. Go for it!!


  6. Hi Annalisa – looks like you’ve had some lovely comments and ideas here .. and offers of beta readers … so good luck – it will all come together … cheers Hilary


  7. I especially adore epilogues. Sometimes I like prologues, but mostly when they’re really short and REALLY relevant. The epilogue feels like icing on the cake. Now that the journey is over, I get one last moment with my beloved characters. *sigh*


  8. Wow! Multiple pages with no edits? That’s impressive. I think I had that happen once with my last round of red line edits—and that was because there were only three words on the page. 🙂

    I have absolutely no problems with prologues or epilogues, so long as they suit the story. Sometimes, they’re just needed.

    Happy writing!


Thanks for reading. I'd love to know what you think.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.